Game Review

Metroid II: Return of Samus (1991) [Game Boy]

85ebc02c269f4e58ec56621bd0b17eff.png

My mommy always said there were no monsters–no real ones–but there are.
-Newt to Ripley, Aliens

 

 

abxy1 “The following is a contributor post by the ABXY Mage.”

Sequel. It’s a term that can evoke both excitement and vitriol. There are a dozen different opinions about sequels. Every once in a while, a game is so perfect that you aren’t sure if you really even want another installment (you know you do, we’re all so greedy). Sometimes a sequel can kill an entire series (what game did you think of? I thought of Earthworm Jim 3D and I haven’t even actually played it). Sometimes, you hope the initial game is successful enough to spawn a sequel so that the developers have a chance to fix the things you didn’t like in the first one.

What do you expect from a sequel when the original was on a more powerful system, though?

Metroid Save

In the chronology of the series, as it stands today, there are five games between the original Metroid and Metroid II. However, at the time of its release, it was the immediate follow-up to the NES classic. Expectations and hopes were high. As is often the case with sequels, it received mixed reviews upon its release. Some people liked the changes, some hated them. Some hated the graphics, some loved the detail improvements. Much like Zelda II: The Adventure of Link, Metroid II is more accurately critiqued in retrospect.

Metroid 2 Arachnus

When we last left the galaxy’s best space hunter, Samus Aran, she had infiltrated the Space Pirates’ base on Zebes, defeated them and Mother Brain, and destroyed the base with an explosive time bomb. Interestingly, it is at this point in the recap of the story, the instruction booklet happens to say, “Her [Samus’] destruction of the reactivated Mother Brain at the center of the fortress crushed the pirates’ evil plans.”

…”destruction of the reactivated Mother Brain”…

At the time of Metroid II’s release, and the time I am writing this (April 2018), Metroid and its remake, Metroid: Zero Mission, are the first game(s) in the chronology. So why, and how, was Mother Brain RE-activated? What happened to Mother Brain before?

REactivatedMotherBrain

Anyway, where were we? Oh, right…

Samus singlehandedly conquered Zebes, Kraid, Ridley, and Mother Brain, then blew up their base. Sometime after this, the Galactic Federation decided that the Metroid were too dangerous to be allowed to survive. So, they sent another research vessel to SR388. The purpose of this expedition was to find out whether or not there were more living Metroid still on the planet.

Metroid 2 Metroid Shell

Shortly after the research ship arrived on SR388, all contact with the crew was lost.

The Federation Police immediately sent in a search and rescue team, and guess what happened to them? Well, if you guessed “they also were never heard from again!” then you guessed right.

After this second tragedy, the Galactic Federation decided to act upon the assumption that the Metroid must be alive and active on SR388, hiding, possibly deep underground. The Federation called all of the galaxy’s representatives together for an emergency congress. The unanimous decision? Send Samus Aran to SR388 with an order to destroy all Metroid.

metroid 2 ship

Following their success with Metroid, Nintendo R&D1 took on the task of creating a portable Metroid adventure for the Game Boy, a sequel but on a smaller scale than its predecessor. In retrospect, the results are not surprising. Several new power-ups, advancement of the story, and familiar elements mixed with a smaller world, graphical restrictions, and unfamiliar elements.

Having just played this game for the first time, and having not yet played the remake, I still have to say that it’s about time they remade this game. After the original Metroid, I don’t think anybody wanted a smaller, more restricted Metroid game.

Metroid 2 Bomb Chozo

 

 

The 8-Bit Review
visual Visuals: 4/10
It’s an overall improvement from the first game. Sure, it’s not in color, unless you play the Game Boy Color version, which looks almost like it probably would have been made for the NES, but Samus’ suit is much more detailed. And not just her regular Power Suit, either, but the Varia Suit is also more detailed, with this being the first game to feature the now iconic, larger, rounded shoulders. These detail changes and additions were actually the result of the game’s lack of color and need for distinction between the two suits. Sometimes restrictions can lead to innovation. Unfortunately, the same didn’t hold true for the environments as they are almost all just bland rocky areas.

While Metroid II has more enemies than the first game, a lot of their designs are pretty boring. It’s not just their designs though. A lot of the enemies have very boring and simple movement patterns. A lot of them pose very little threat at all. I suppose this could be because they aren’t really enemies as much as they are planetary life but the same case could be made for the original Metroid and those enemies seemed much more hostile.

Metroid Mutations Manual

The different mutations of the Metroid are pretty cool. Well, for the most part. Considering the switch to monochrome, the Metroid you recognize from the original look pretty darn good. It’s very cool to get to see what they look like as they grow or evolve as well. The Alpha and Gamma Metroid both look interesting, menacing, and logically designed. The Zeta and Omega Metroid both look like intimidating designs (just look in the instruction booklet) but are unfortunately products of the Game Boy’s size limitations. Much like Kraid and Ridley in the first installment, the Zeta and Omega Metroid seem far smaller and simpler than they should be.

 Audio: 3/10

While Ryoji Yoshitomi did not do the music for the original Metroid, he clearly attempted to carry on the musical themes and ideas from it. Unfortunately, he falls short. And, once again, you won’t be tapping along to this soundtrack. We’re familiar with the idea of silence being used to increase the feeling of solitude and unknown, but here, silence mostly exists in short bursts or easily measured beats.

In the few areas where silence is used in excess, the non-silent parts of the score are almost completely covered by the sound effects. This all but eliminates the atmosphere of suspense and unsureness. Instead, most of the soundtrack comes across like a Metroid cover band that after decades of playing Metroid songs decided to try writing their own stuff. It sounds very similar but without being as good or effective.

All of this is perfectly exampled in the title screen. It starts off new but familiar. Any fan of the first game playing this for the first time must have been pumping so much adrenaline for the first fifteen seconds of this song. Then, the familiar theme kicks in. Almost immediately there are too many notes. It’s familiar, but somehow wrong; it’s a new twist on something that should not have been twisted.

Again, the majority of the sound effects sound only slightly better than Atari era sound effects. However, unlike the sounds in the first game, a lot of what you hear in this game gets very annoying very fast. The Ice Beam, jumping, the Wave Beam, and taking damage all get very tiresome quickly. On top of that, this game not only doesn’t have the wonderful bomb drop sound, but it also changes the sound of the Screw Attack. I highly suggest listening to something else while you play this one.

 Gameplay: 5/10
One of Metroid II’s biggest blunders is that the gameplay is oversimplified. The average person, if not every person, wants more out of a sequel. Metroid II, instead, offers less. Maybe it’s the product of being a Game Boy game and not an NES release but that would only excuse some of its faults.

Metroid 2 Spider Ball

First, let’s look at what it did improve. It introduced the Spring Ball, which allowed you to jump while in the Morph Ball. This is something that everyone wanted to do in Metroid. It also gave us the Spider Ball. This gave you the power to cling to walls and ceilings while in the Morph Ball. The Space Jump gave Samus the ability to jump infinitely. However, it almost makes the Spider Ball redundant once you acquire it.

Bosses. The first game had Kraid, Ridley, and Mother Brain. That’s it. Three. Metroid II has 39 Metroid in five different mutation and difficulty stages plus the Queen Metroid. Going this far to the other side of the spectrum, however, kind of makes the boss fights less exciting.

And now for the changes that were less than good. Did you occasionally get tired of going through areas again and again in search of your next passage in Metroid? Well, fear not, this game includes whole zones you won’t ever see again after a short period.

Worried you won’t know where to go again? Well, each new zone is blocked off by some kind of lava or acid that Samus cannot get through. Once you defeat the required amount of Metroid in an area, there is an earthquake. Naturally, once the quake is over, the place where the acid/lava was blocking your path is now clear.

As a result of the story and objective, your mission to eliminate the Metroid is clear. However, Metroid II took it one step further and gave you a meter that counts down how many total Metroid you have left to defeat. This, in conjunction with the quakes, makes retracing a lot of your steps unlikely and getting lost even less common.

Metroid Meter

While you couldn’t go so far as to say Metroid II is linear, when you compare it to Metroid and the expectations of the time, it is much more–and much too–linear for the followup to the original.

 Accessibility: 7/10

Metroid II Acid

Given its increased linearity and the obvious cues it provides, Metroid II is quite a bit more accessible than the first game. The controls all make sense, and the biggest struggle is bombing while in Spider Ball on cave ceilings. But, most of those are for non-essentials anyway. Unlike the original Metroid, the instruction booklet is not mandatory for beating Metroid II.

diff Challenge: 5/10

Matroid II Manual

Aside from the final battle with the Queen Metroid, by far, the hardest part of Metroid II is having enough missiles when you need them. With missiles being the only way to defeat the Metroid, you use them constantly and running out of missiles in the middle of a battle with a Metroid is really annoying. Luckily there are Missile Batteries peppered throughout the planet where you can fully refill your supply. In fact, most of the retreading you will need to do comes from having to refill your ammo.

Knowing what to do and where to go is much easier in this game than it was in the original. The secret paths are easier to find. A majority of the regular enemies pose little to no threat. Metroid II also brought save points to the series, making game overs not quite the hellish nightmare they once were.

replay Replayability: 3/10

Metroid 2 Enemy

With the simplified exploration and decreased difficulty, the game becomes a much more straightforward adventure. This eliminates the struggle that probably led to so many people replaying Metroid again and again on the NES. Surely, this game’s only replayability, which is long since gone, existed only because it was the only portable Metroid at the time, and everyone only had so many games for their Game Boys to begin with.

unique Uniqueness: 6/10
Unfortunately, Metroid II: Return of Samus abandons some of the mechanics that made the original Metroid so original. If you’ve played any of the other games in the series (and at this point, I’ve only played Metroid, Metroid II, and Super Metroid), then this game will likely feel almost incomplete. When you get to the end, you’ll probably think to yourself, “that was it?”

Metroid 2 Queen Metroid

Having said that, it does retain the all-four-directions-scrolling, the giant map instead of levels, and the need for power-ups that allow you to access new areas. So it still has several of the key components of the still, at the time, newly evolving Metroidvania genre. Too bad it didn’t do anything to push the genre forward.

pgrade My Personal Grade: 4/10

Metroid II Ending

I could play Super Metroid endlessly. I could play Metroid several more times. I could play this game again… I guess. It kind of felt like this should have been the first Metroid, and then the NES one is where they go with it, surpassing expectations. Instead, they didn’t meet them. Several cool concepts, multiple memorable items, and key arc moments for the Metroid story as an entire series just aren’t enough to make it the game everyone wants and wanted it to be. Metroid II: Return of Samus is one small step back before the giant leap for Metroid.

Aggregated Score: 4.6

 

The ABXY Mage leads a double life of unfathomable smoothness, if his expertise in jazz is any indication. Music maker, fandangoist, writer, you can find this hip cat as ABXY Reviews on Twitter and on YouTube.

 

Did you enjoy this post? Consider becoming a Warrior of Light and join us in restoring integrity and quality to games writing. We specialize in long-form, analytical reviews and we aim to expand into a community of authors with paid contributors, a fairer and happier alternative to mainstream games writing! See our Patreon page for more info!

becomeapatronbanner

12 replies »

  1. Nice work!

    I’m in the minority in that I preferred Metroid II to Metroid I. Very different kinda of games, Metroid II isn’t really a “metroidvania” like Metroids I and III. But it reminded me of a Game Boy version of Aliens – close up view restricting your vision, and a dark feeling of being in “their territory” with a bit of ambiguity in that your mission is genocide. I didn’t even mind the no-backtracking because I finished the game (never finished Metroid 1).

    But yeah, if you were looking for “Metroid Plus more” this wasn’t it.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Excellent review and I really felt like I inhabited your experience this time, like I’d gotten a taste of what it is like to play Metroid II for the first time. A reviewer couldn’t hope for more than that! I feel sorry for the Game Boy sometimes. It was a great early handheld but it couldn’t compete with what the NES and SNES were doing. I thought the first song you posted was pretty great but when I got to the second, I was all “yuck”… I remember those warbling, tinny shrieks on a lot of GB games…

    Liked by 1 person

    • That’s terrific, thank you! Nobody ever talks about this game, so I had no idea what to expect. I felt kind of how I imagine I would have felt when it was first released. So, I tried to get that feeling across.
      Yeah, I posted that first song because it’s the only song in the entire game that I liked. I think I actually said “yuck” or “boo” out loud during the title screen, haha. they really butchered that great theme… if you can get through the 30-something seconds it takes to get the recognizable part, haha.

      Liked by 1 person

      • It’s tough to nail that, yeah. What would it have been like with the anticipation of a second Metroid way back then? Hard to say without having experienced it ourselves.

        Have you thought about what you want to write for the Super Metroid entry, the crown jewel?

        Liked by 1 person

        • I have not. It will probably have to wait until have Mr. Cube and TR3 anyway. So, I have some time to think about it. I’m kind of intimidated by it actually. I love the game so much, I don’t want to write something that doesn’t do it justice, haha.

          Liked by 1 person

Kindly leave a civil and decent comment like a good human being

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s